Wednesday, 21 September 2011

Supply and Demand

A friend of mine remarked recently that she was surprised that Britain, unlike Germany and Italy, was not making more of the nuclear catastrophe in Japan. A recent item in the Guardian gives some idea why. emails-nuclear-uk-government-fukushima


Here the Guardian reproduce some 80 emails between Government officials and the British nuclear industry. These show that within 2 days  of start of the Japanese disaster the government and industry had their heads together rehearsing their lines. The disaster started on March the 11th and by March the 13th, a Sunday, the British Government had prepared a,'Let's not rush to judgement' announcement. Well they certainly had. On the day the press release came out the Fukushima reactor building 3 exploded.


This was when Energy Secretary Chris Huhne mocked continental politicians, those excitable Germans, for their response to the crises. The stoic British kept to a press strategy that had been worked out the previous weekend. This warned that anti-nuclear types would probably compare the disaster to Chernobel. By the 12th April Japan itself had classified the Fukushima incident as being equivalent to Chernobel.   


The recent revelations regarding News International, the Murdoch news empire, reveal a level of complicity between the press and government.  As regards nuclear power the British Government had decided on its energy policy and it doesn't want to have to go changing it just because of public opinion. Murdoch promised his support to the British government, in return for support of his project to dominate British media. And, perhaps by coincidence, the government had no trouble getting its take on Fukushima into the papers.

Nuclear power is hideously expensive if the costs of incidents like  Fukushima are properly considered. No insurance company will supply cover for a nuclear power station. It is assumed that the government will carry that burden should it be needed. If nuclear power companies had to buy insurance cover on the free market running costs would be much higher. Governments, of course, don't like to remind taxpayers of this important fact, and the nuclear companies certainly don't brag about it. The UK government, in particular, seems to be being led around by the nose by the nuclear industry.

Peak Oil is another issue the British government just doesn't want to think about. The issue driving price is supply and demand. Even the effect of Peak Oil could be cushioned if nations prepare for it and start developing alternatives. If demand reduces before supply starts to decline oil prices don't have to shoot through the roof. This is the lesson of the two big oil crises of the 20th century. These were generated by suppliers intentionally restricting supply and this led to some startling price spikes. When demand outstrips supply prices soar and for no additional effort profits increase, and users must belatedly struggle to find alternatives. Thus, it serves the purpose of the oil business to encourage complacency and downplay the prospect of Peak Oil. 




But, while Britain chortles as Jeremy Clarkson and the Daily Mail mock developments in renewable energy Germany is forging ahead. The Fukushima incident served as a catalyst to Germany to declare that it would start to close down all its nuclear power stations. German hopes to produce 35% of all its electricity from renewables by 2020 and 80% by 2050, with a reduction of electricity usage of 50% by 2050.


Currently the anti-renewable lobby claims that all renewable proposals are lacking when it comes to dealing with the fluctuations of supply, windless day = stationary windmill, thus renewables are in trouble. And that  when renewables fail to meet demand additional costs are incurred by starting up hydrocarbon powered peak-load turbines.


Even with non-renewable power, with much of the load carried by nuclear or coal/oil powered generators, peak load turbines are required. Power consumption goes through all kinds of peaks and troughs during a 24 hour cycle and when demand is very low, at night time, a conventional generator plant often has to waste power venting steam because demand is so low. 


A fully developed renewable system can deal with both demand and supply fluctuations. A very mature, low risk, system is possible that stores power by pumping water into elevated resevoirs.



By pumping water to a higher level at times when demand is low or supply high, and allowing it to flow down and drive a generator when demand is high or supply low, the peaks and troughs of demand and supply can be managed.


However, one of the main issues is finding suitable areas for the two essential bodies of water. Now Germany has come up with an innovative concept, the possibility of flooding used up coal mines therefore concealing the reservoirs underground, and finding a use for those exhausted, non-renewable energy sources the coal mines.


Already some 20% of Germany's electrical power comes from renewable sources: Windpower, Biomass, Hydropower and Photovoltaic Solar power. In the UK it's about 6%. No prizes then for guessing which nation will develop the essential renewable power technologies of the future.

Sunday, 4 September 2011

Further down the Hubbert curve

In the last blog I spoke of modeling a fictional world - Beyond Peak Oil. Any real model of the economy, on the downslope of the Hubbert curve, must be immensely complicated, and prone to error. For writing spec. fiction we can use simpler methods. Suppose we look at some key events  of the upslope of the Hubburt curve and revoke them, in the order they took place.




Looking at the last 100 years and projecting forward I can 'predict' an economy changing back from its present  2% of workforce employed in agriculture back to some 20% by 2060.

The exact timescale is in question. The steepness of the downslope of the Hubbert curve depends on demand for oil and its products. If these stay high we can expect a steep downslope which compresses the timescale. If demand reduces the rewind takes longer. Of course, if you are in the oil business the goal is to maximise profits which is best done by ensuring that demand exceeds supply as much as possible, as it has done in the oil crises of the last century.

The story is set in 2060. Describing a society that is an exact mirror of the past period is not interesting. We would, I reckon, be able to maintain some of our technology. A society with computers, the internet and television but without mass, cheap travel.



There is still oil, but it is very expensive. There is some combustion powered aviation, for the super rich. You can buy a small electric car as good as a 2010 combustion powered car but, if you are member of the 20% of the agricultural workforce you can't afford one. You either walk to work, or if you are lucky, go by bike. But you do consider yourself lucky because you are employed and with the healthcare benefits of an employed citizen.

Working people cannot afford to travel much. They see the past century, the Time of Plenty, which is accesible via TV and films, as a lost golden age of apparently universal wealth.

The middle class are much reduced as a percentage of the workforce, many formerly middle class professions are automated or have disappeared as a consequence of the increased cost of hydrocarbons. But the lifestyle of the middle class is superior to the present day.  



The upper class, the super rich, are almost invisible to the naked eye. They travel the world in combustion powered aircraft. They have ownership of wilderness areas and have longer, fulfilled, healthy lives. Just occasionally they come down to earth to influence the world of men.

In some countries there is a virtually abandoned underclass with no rights, no healthcare and almost no social mobility. Such is my model of 2060.

Tuesday, 30 August 2011

Sliding down the Hubbert Curve

There have been numerous TV shows and countless newspaper and internet articles on the subject of peak oil.  As someone with an interest in writing SF  the world beyond peak oil is thought provoking. (I happen to believe that SF should have some resemblance to historical analysis to the extent that we try and look at how technology/economy changes society. )



The oil experts agree that world oil production will follow a bell curve. Above is the Hubbert prediction from 1956. Beyond the peak of production, which predictions say we are now close to, although oil is still plentiful, costs start to rise.



Above is a graph of inflation adjusted oil prices (1946 - 2010). The effects of two oil crises appear as perturbations on the graph. It might be tempting to think that peak oil will be nothing more than another perturbation. And yet the price history we have seen, with a year 2008 maximum followed by a recession lead slump, is only the behaviour of prices on the upslope of the Hubbert curve. The upslope is a time of increased production where economies of scale are reducing real production and distribution costs. 

The characteristics of the upslope of the Hubbert oil curve are the enabling of new technologies that depend on hydrocarbons. The upslope brought mechanised agriculture, car ownership, agrichemicals, plastics, mass airtravel. And a new, much larger middleclass. The nature of the 20th century is bound to the upslope of the Hubbert curve. 

What we don't know is what the downslope will bring. Maybe the reverse?

In Britain petrol is now costing over 6 pounds per gallon. Even now, before we start our slide down the Hubbert curve, this is  nearly 3 times the cost of eqivelant off-peak electricity.  (1 gallon of petrol is approximately equivalent 43.7 kw/hour. 1 kw/hour cost 4.95 pence, off peak) 

Modern agriculture is very energy intensive. A recent documentary stated that about 100 calories of energy in hydrocarbons is needed to produce 1 calorie of food energy. And this is not counting transportation and packaging. Modern farming is highly mechanised and artificial fertilizers and insecticides are derived from hydrocarbons. High energy agriculture  has made the developed world very efficient in labour terms. (In Britain now only 1.4 % of the workforce work the land. In the USA it's 1.9%.)

So, can this kind of agriculture be sustained against rising prices for hydrocarbons?
After the fall of the Soviet Union Cuba went through an agricultural crises.
Cuban Ag crises Suddenly it found itself unable to grow food in the previous, high energy, fashion that its alliance with the Soviet Union had permitted. It had to back pedal. Currently, in Cuba, over 20% of the workforce are involved in agriculture. This amount of labour is caused by Cuba's inability to afford high energy agriculture.
The Power of Community: How Cuba Survived Peak Oil


We might have to change the way we do agriculture and go back to labour intensive farming. Not that this is entirely a bad thing. Organic farming produces healthier, tastier food. It is less energy intensive and eliminates many agrichemicals. Moreover, fresh locally produced food is mandated when high energy transport and preservation is not possible.

What else?
In Germany it is claimed that 1 in 7 of all jobs are car industry related. This is the kind of argument that has allowed the German car industry to lever about a billion euros in tax credits out of the taxpayer towards developing alternate fuelled vehicles. (BMW have just claimed the largest profits in the company's history. Free market fundamentalists may explain, if they can, why these car makers need to be given a state hand out to enable them to develop the technology to stay in business.)  Never mind, it is technically possible to develop renewable energy cars. Within ten years or so, the technology for renewable energy cars, (electric or hydrogen) and as good as petroleum powered, in terms of range, performance and general reliability will likely be developed.

A more interesting question is, will the market for mass volume cars still be around? If agriculture is restructured to be labour intensive somebody is going to have to be working the land. Agricultural work never was well paid. And we cannot easily go back to the farming of earlier times. Farms are much larger now, and ownership is not widely distributed. The efficiency gains of the last 60 years caused many small farms to consolidate into larger ones. The agricultural jobs of the future will be for employees, not owner occupiers.

What if we go to Cuba levels of agricultural employment?
Not since 1931 has 20% percent of the US labour force been employed in agriculture.
The 1930s were not a time of high car ownership. The wealthy middle classes could afford them, it helped if, say you were a doctor and you needed one for work. But for an agricultural worker car ownership was totally out of the question. 

By 1930 agriculture had become somewhat mechanised, we didn't yet have the efficiency gains due to agrichemicals. As we slide further down the Hubbert curve we might expect further enlargement  to the the agricultural labour force if mechanisation becomes too expensive to sustain. (In 1900 41% were employed on the land. In a sense the early mechanisation of agriculture made the huge standing armies of the First World War possible. Those people were freed from the land for the battlefield.)

So where will these additional agricultural workers come from?
The service sector includes air and road transport which are vulnerable to fuel costs. And the new labour intensive agriculture will be local sold, we don't expect to shift food huge distances any more. Airtransport and numerous supplier businesses will also suffer. Despite the fantastic efficiency of combustion engined airliners the increasing cost of fuel will limit demand. (Electric powered mass airtransport is unlikely.) 


Food will cost more which means less disposable income. This will further hit service sector jobs and the car market. Expect fewer jobs in  manufacturing as well. In short, there will be no shortage of formerly well paid middle class types  to work the land.

But there will be some new jobs. Mass transportation systems that lend themselves to electric power will be in demand once more. Electric power, from nuclear or renewable sources will continue. Just don't expect it to get cheaper.

However, one way or the other, it seems likely that the middle classes, as a percentage of the population, are set to grow smaller. A reversal of a trend that's been under way for all of the twentieth century, in short, this could get very interesting....

Tuesday, 12 July 2011

Phone Hacking

Amidst the welter of mainstream news regarding phone hacking and dodgy behaviour by the British press I chip with a certain reluctance. Phone hacking suggests some technology wizardry and invokes some imagery of a bored but brilliant teanager exercising huge technical skill. In fact 'caller ID spoofing,' the technique probably used here, is relatively simple and involves calling the voice mail message centre from a phone with a caller ID that appears to be the same as the number of the victims phone.



Caller ID is the feature that allows you to see who an incoming call is coming from.  A number of companies exist which offer a caller ID spoofing service. To use a Caller ID spoofing service, customers pay in advance for a PIN, allowing them to make a call for a certain amount of time. Customers dial the number given to them by the company and enter their PIN. Then they enter the number they wish to call.
https://www.telespoof.com/
To access someone else's voicemail, which happened in the Dowler case, the number to call is the number of the voicemail service of the victims cellphone service provider. They must enter the number they wish to appear as the Caller ID as the number of the victims phone. When the call connects to the voicemail service the system uses the caller ID number to connect the call to the correct mailbox. Sometimes a PIN code will be also needed but these are often not used or will be 0000 or 1234 or some other easily guessed number. 
Then, when the hacker is into the voicemail system 'as the victim', can he replay or even delete the victims messages. 
Caller_ID_spoofing - Wiki
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2006/08/paris_hilton_ma/
The fact that this was happening became obvious to Britain's Prince William when he got onto his own voicemail and discovered messages tagged as SAVED MESSAGES that he'd not heard before. Someone else had been into his voice mail and replayed them first, while they were still NEW MESSAGES. This ought to be something of a give away for even the slowest Inspector Plod but even where Royal security was concerned the police have been reluctant to persue the matter.
In the case of the murdered school girl, Milly Dowler, her voice mail message was hacked into repeatedly and the messages of family and friends, desperate to get in contact with her, became news. The individuals involved in hacking were perhaps being paid on a message by message basis and finally when the voice mail was full and no new messages could be stored the hackers took it upon themselves to delete old messages to make room for new ones. By this stage not even Plod of the Yard could ignore the fact that unathorised people were accessing private messages and interfering with a murder investigation. 
Now, it seems, this 'revelation' has brought down one of Britains oldest popular tabloids. Big deal, there's plenty more bildzeitung keen to take over from the NOTW. Rebecca Brooks, CEO of the NOTW, is still claiming to have known nothing about it. Journalist on the NOTW claim that even the office cat knew about the phone hacking. What a disaster, and what a piss poor show by the police.

Saturday, 2 July 2011

Sir Harold Ridley

It seems that I have a cataract. A few weeks ago I realised that the vision in my right eye was rather blurred, a visit to the optical shop showed no improvement with various lenses. A visit to the local eye doctor brought forth a, "I have good news and bad news." (I'm not sure if all German optical specialist favour Pythonesque humour but mine did.) A cataract is the condition where the normally clear natural lens of the eye becomes opaque. The modern treatment calls for the removal of the old lens and replacement with an implant.

Cataract treatment is one of the oldest surgical treatments devised and dates back to, amazingly, the 6th century BC. (Descriptions of this early treatment are not for the sqeamish.) At the time, with no possibility of vision enhancement using glasses, the utility of the treatment was dubious. Later, when eyeglasses became available, around the 1700s, the improvements in vision made the surgery more useful although the correcting spectacle lenses needed had many shortcomings.

It was work of an Englishman,Sir Harold Ridley who pioneered the use of lens implants. It was known from wartime experience that shards of Perspex, the transparent plastic used in aircraft canopies, could be buried in the body for years without being rejected. Ridley devised a Perspex lens replacement. (He worked with an optician, John Pike, of Rayners the lens makers, and a chemist, Dr John Holt, of ICI)  Other colleagues devised ways of sterilising the plastic lens.


The first lens was implanted in 1949. At the time  prosthetic surgery was almost unknown. Now we have a whole global industry built around eye surgery alone. It's remarkable to note that all the initial development and risk was taken on privately by Ridley and his colleagues and played down because of the revolutionary nature of the work.

This pioneering work met with considerable resistance within the establishment of British optical surgeons. Sir Stewart Duke Elder, who had appointed Harold to Moorfield's eye hospital before the war, had already fallen out with him. Harold was a highly skilled surgeon and after doing good surgical work on combat casualties during the Battle of Britain was banished, by Duke Elder, to Ghana. Harold was initially disapointed by this as Ghana was well outside the expected combat area where he thought he could be most usefully employed. But banishment to this backwater didn't stop Harold Ridley working. In Ghana he researched various causes of blindness and with colleagues made great progress on river blindness which was a huge problem in there.

After the war, and Harold's groundbreaking work on lens implant surgery, Duke Elder was still set against him. As a result ocular implant surgery gained quicker acceptance in US, and elsewhere, than in the United Kingdom.

Nevertheless, Harold continued with other developments and pioneered the use of electronic television systems to image the eye, initially in black and white and in 1950 using one of the first colour TV systems in Britain.

In spite of his pioneering work Harold was not knighted until he was over 90, long after the demise of Duke Elder. And then only thanks to former colleagues and students and the intervention of Hilary Clinton and Cherie Blair. Finally, Sir Harold was properly honoured within his own lifetime. It seems that the influence of the enemy he had made at the start of his career, Sir Stewart Duke Elder, who had also been the Queen's eye surgeon, had lasted a long time.


I'm to have my cataract operation on the 18th of July. More on this later.

Thursday, 9 June 2011

Haus der Kunst

The Haus der Kunst (House of Art),  is an art gallery in Munich which was opened in 1937. It is perched on the side of the Englischer Garten, a Munich city park that was founded in 1789 and styled after the British landscape parks of Capability Brown.


The building was inaugurated as the House of German Art with a huge display of Große Deutsche Kunstausstellung ("Great German art exhibition"). This was intended to be an antidote to what Hitler had called, entartete kunst (Decadant Art). which is to say, anything abstract or modern.  One imagines Hitler as being the kind of chap who would say, "I don't know much about art but I know what I like". The German state owned art galleries were cleared of any art that could be  categorised thus and this was brought to Munich for display and eventual disposal.

The pieces were put on display along with mocking slogans and the price paid by the previous government shown. The Weimar Republic is now famous for the rampant financial inflation of the time. Yet, the time of this first German democratic government had been one of huge creativity. This included not just the classic arts of painting and sculpture, but also films, architecture and interior design.

Amongst those deemed decadent were Bauhaus, the group of cutting edge building and interior designers. Bauhaus were designing furniture in the 1920s that still looks modern today.


Cubism, Surrealism and Impressionism were also deemed decadent art. The work of lesser known artists was burnt with some ceremony. But the Nazi regime was not one to miss a chance to make money, and all the valuable pieces were sold abroad.  The art veto extended  to popular music, especially jazz because of its ethnic roots. They had many musicians and much music banned.


The famous jazz guitarist, Django Reinhart was extraordinarily lucky to survive the war. He was in Paris when the Nazi's conquered it. As a gypsy, and a jazz musician, he had two strikes against him. Many gypsies, but not Reinhart, ended their days in concentration camps.  

After the Große Deutsche Kunstausstellung, the Haus of Kunst was filled with much more conventional art.  Portrait painters, recognising the way the wind was blowing, produced endless portraits of the Fuerher. Included this extraordinary Knight in shining armour.


Check this link for more examples.

The new, preferred art, was also to depict life in Germany and this one, "Der Führer Spricht" (The Führer Speaks) is intended to depict a typical German rural family listening to the radio. It might have appeared in the American Saturday Evening Post.

By 1945, the Haus of Kunst had survived the bombing. The US Army turned part of it into an Officers Club. But, a few years later, the Haus of Kunst was back in business as an art gallery.  Among the first exhibits were the previously shunned work of modern artists and Picasso's Gurnecia was on display.



Gurnecia depicts the Spanish town that was bombed by the Luftwaffe in the Spanish civil war. It is abstract but its meaning is clear enough.

Since the war years the patrons of the Haus de Kunst have, metaphorically speaking, continued to stick two fingers up at the Fuerher. The Haus de Kunst has no permanent displays, but provides a temporary home for travelling exhibitions from around the world -  the most abstract, avant guard works,  in the most way out style imaginable.
http://www.hausderkunst.de/

More on Hitler's art.

Thursday, 26 May 2011

The growth cycle of a technology.

Where are we in the development cycle of the electric car? Can we look at other technologies and decide how mature the electric car is? A model for technology development might be:

1) Initial work by dedicated visionaries. Building and improvising many parts.

2) High cost, early models. Rich mans toy stage. Techniques and components are borrowed from existing technologies. Profits are starting to be made.

3) Volume, mass production. Huge industrial base. Ongoing development is cross fertilised from helper technologies. The technology is so significant that the base product inspires developments that enhance other technologies.



The combustion engined car and commercial passenger aviation are at stage 3. Cars are now universal and mass air travel is trivially cheap. By comparison, personal flight technology, today only available in owner flown helicopters, is still a largely impractical, expensive way for millionaires to kill themselves.  This technology is still at stage 2, the rich man's toy stage.

Universal communication, cellphones etc is well into stage 3. It too had a rich mans toy stage. Back in the 1960s it was possible to have a car telephone installed, if you were rich enough. Even thought the technology was little different to a police radio, with a telephone operator to dial through your connection to a landline phone, the basic need, for continuous, on demand communications was being realised.

When an existing solution is already in use a new technology has to be very good indeed before it can replace it. In the 1930s a couple of visionaries, one in Germany and one in England, developed the gas turbine jet engine. They came up with a technological step change so great that it was eventually worth while designing brand new aircraft and much new infrastructure to best exploit it.

With the electric car, production vehicles are derived from existing combustion powered designs. The energy storage systems are still largely improvised from those designed from vastly different, much lower power applications. The Tesla high performance electric sports car, for example, is based on ancestor technology. The frame and chassis are developed from a combustion powered Lotus Elise, and the energy storage system is derived from some 6,831 cells of the battery type found in laptop computers. These characteristics, and the high cost, lodge what is possibly the best example of the electric car, the Tesla firmly in stage 2.

Battery technology has improved greatly in the last thirty years. Energy density, the amount of power that can be stored in a certain weight of storage, has increased greatly, although it is still well below that of petrol. Additionally, combustion fuels have the advantage of reducing weight as they are depleted, a discharged battery weighs as much as a charged one. But, none of the battery improvements thus far have been as part of a development for electric vehicles, they were mainly developed to improve the performance of mobile phones and portable computers.

Recent years have brought improvements in electric motors. Werner Von Siemens invented the DC, direct current, electric motor in the late 1800s. The AC, alternating current, induction motor was invented by Nicolas Tesla in 1924. An AC motor is much more efficient than a DC motor. AC motors lack the mechanical brushes that must continuously break-reverse-make the circuit within a DC motor. (the things you see sparking away inside cheap electric toys) For an AC motor some form of alternating current power supply, not just a battery, is necessary. Miniature AC induction motors were used in some of the first airborne analogue computers devised in the 1940s. The aircraft that used them had to carry around their own source of AC power.

But, by the early 1990s, the development of microprocessors meant that small battery powered systems could use brushless AC motors. Power switching and control was then localised to individual motors. This makes for much more efficiency.

But that's not the end of it. Combustion engines have their own disadvantages that we just don't notice anymore. They work best at a particular speed, around 3000 revolution per min. As a result of this combustion cars have to carry around gearboxes in order that the most efficient engine speed be matched to the road speed. Piston engined aircraft do something similar by varying the pitch of the propeller as the airspeed changes. But, the electric motor inherently generates high torque at low speed. The Tesla sports car has no gear selection box, or clutch, it has a single speed transmission, and a forward, reverse and off switch. Although the energy density of gasoline is still much higher than batteries electric drive offers some sure savings. But the development stage 2 practice of borrowing technology does not yet allow full exploitation of these advantages.

A blank sheet electric car design would have a specifically designed automotive energy storage, using the latest battery chemistry. It would have a specifically designed drive system, probably all wheel drive with one motor, direct drive per wheel. A control system would be needed to keep it all working within safe limits and to precisely control the motors. Arguably, the most difficult part of the job would be that one, developing the safety critical software to get the best out of it. The fact that it hasn't happened yet isn't because the Tesla designer are idiots, they are working pragmatically to a budget. This requires employing as much existing technology as possible,while in stage 2 of the (electric car) technology development cycle.

An all out effort in electric car design could yield a much more effective technology quite quickly but in order to do that the initiative probably has to be taken out of the hands of private industry. Despite the broad claims of the free market fundamentalists private industry rarely pioneers brand new technology. The early history of the jet engine is a good example. Whittle, the British jet pioneer, tried and failed to interest the engine companies who would, post war, make massive sales, and profits from the jet engine. Even the Royal Air Force gave Whittle more help than the British aero engine industry and, but for the wartime opportunity of near limitless, taxpayer funded development, the technology might have languished in the doldrums for years. (or been developed elsewhere)

The electric car is also disadvantaged by the highly developed state of combustion engined cars. The newest developments in energy storage and motors are, not yet, enough to dislodge the combustion car. Petrol is a great means of storing energy in a very compact form, it has a very high energy density. Even the best new batteries still fall short of this. Energy density of a lead acid battery, 0.14 Mj/kg. A Lithium Ion battery 2.5 Mj/kg. -- Gasoline, 46.4 Mj/kg.

There is, perhaps, one other factor which is inhibiting electric car development, the fact that there are competing, energy storage systems that might turn out to be be more effective than batteries. The hydrogen fuel cell, or flywheel technology might turn out to be more practical than batteries.

The primary problem is one of improving energy storage. Out of this will eventually come new technologies that will find other applications. Amongst these, perhaps, local storage of renewable energy. At the moment homes with rooftop photovoltaic cells get financial benefits by selling surplus power back to the grid. It could be more efficient if it were stored and used locally, at night time.

However, it will be ironic, after the motor car has burned up most of  the hydrocarbons, if the next big technology breakthrough for renewable energy comes as a result of car development.