Sunday, 6 February 2011

Tinkering on the Cutting Edge

The wealthy upper classes of 18th century Britain and their patronage of science has been well documented. Indeed, for some enthusiasts, actual scientific research was the hobby. The connection between developing new technologies and their support and development by enthusiastic hobbyists, is perhaps less well known.

In recent times we have seen the introduction of new technologies such as the mobile phone. Technologies that spring, almost complete and perfect, onto the market and rapidly become essentials, world wide. This has not always been the case and a number of now perfected technologies that we also consider to be vital were once subject to protracted development essential in the hands of amateur enthusiasts. While I do not claim that amateurs invented much actual technology it was often down to amateur users, the beta testers for photography, radio and theme computer to create a market and find ways to use the various technologies that might otherwise have been short lived fads.

The first photographs date back to 1826 and the pioneers discovered various photo sensitive chemicals and developed the processes. When it first emerged photography was seen as  a combination of art and technology, and the enthusiasts were the well to do middle classes with some hand skills and the scientific background  to understand the technical considerations. It's hard now to imagine the thrill it must have been to create the very first photographic images. Image creation had been the preserve of skilled artists who, building on centuries of technique and painstaking craftsmanship,  drew or painted. That image creation should now be possible, not just for artists, but for technical types must have been thrilling.

Eastman Kodak had a commercial system in place by 1870, where enthusiasts could send a wooden camera containing a reel of exposed film for development and printing. Nevertheless, for a long time, real mastery of photography required home laboratories - darkrooms. A photographer was someone who took the picture and developed and fixed the prints. There was, perhaps, another reason that some of the early enthusiasts liked to be in charge of developing their own pictures, and this was for the  creation of the first nude studies. It seems that even from the earliest days of imagery that, that very male pre-occupation, the nude female form, has featured. This preoccupation would drive first still photography, the Polaroid camera, some of the earliest motion pictures and eventually home video.

Theodore Miller, for example, had a huge interest in photography and made many nude studies of  his daughter Lee. He experimented with stereo photographs and passed his talent and interest onto Lee. By the 1930s, photograph had pushed the traditional artist away from the school of realism into surrealism. A few years later, working in the photographic darkroom, the experimental artist and photographer Man Ray, assisted  by Lee Miller, devised darkroom techniques which allowed photography too, to explore surrealism.



Radio came in to being at the start of the 20th century. The thermionic valve, the first truly effective means of creating high frequency amplification and oscillation, (the two vital building blocks of radio) now became possible. The valve, or tube to Americans, is a precursor to the transistor which is now completely ubiquitous. Valves were much larger, much less reliable and given to varying in performance over their rather short lifetime.  Much early electronc equipment tended to behave in a undeterministic fashion. While broadcast reception was possible with factory made receivers it was the enthusiastic amateurs building large aerials and coaxing the best out of their, often homemade receivers, who reigned supreme. Early radio  was troublesome and quirky but the opportunity it gave, to tune in to London or the other big cities in Europe made it worth the effort.

By the mid 1930s the first attempts at television broadcasting were made. Just in time, as it happened, to give the new electronics industry experience in building powerful transmitters and to seed the cathode ray tube industry.  Radar, which came in just before the war, benefited from both these technologies. If good radio reception had been a challenge television required extreme ingenuity on the part of camera and receiver designers. Eventually cohorts of locally based technicians accumulated tow run little radio and television specialist workshops, countrywide.



Britain, it seems, was particularly well blessed with radio enthusiasts and when the Second World War started these men were in great demand as the services recruited, first radio technicians, and then as new equipments were rushed into service, radar technicians. The skills these men had learned, prewar, tinkering with radios, paid off in wartime as good, practical knowledge.

The way different, similar technologies feed and serve each other is never more aptly illustrated than with the symbiosis of radio, television, and radar. After the war this continued and radar providing components, techniques, and skilled technicians  to facilitate building and operation of the early electronic computers.

There have been occasions when  it has been necessary to consult the amateurs because, really, no one else has a clue.  In order to circumvent the restrictions of the First World War peace settlement (which limited the size of the conventional artillery that it could have) the German Army turned to the field of rocketry. Werner Von Braun, a talented young student with an interest in rocketry, was a member of the Spaceflight Society of the Technical University of Berlin. He was given an army grant to peruse his studies. His thesis, Construction, Theoretical, and Experimental Solution to the Problem of the Liquid Propellant Rocket (dated April 16, 1934) remained classified until 1960. Von Braun's V2s begat the Soviet ICBMs and the ensuing technology race eventually begat Project Apollo, and the moon landings. For all Von Braun's Nazi connections his original goal had been, as he told Piccard in 1930, to reach the moon. 


After the Second World War came the start of computer development, and this has been well documented elsewhere. Development was in the hands of the professionals although certainly the first machines had many memory techniques, delay lines and CRT storage systems, borrowed from wartime radar. The first machines were extremely temperamental, this being the early days of discrete semiconductors, and it seems most likely many of the technicians in those early days had followed the radio amateur route and were capable of keeping these temperamental machines going.

There was a great interest in electronics in the 1960s, it was the new technology, and the amateur enthusiast could persue his interest through a variety of popular monthly magazines. 

In the USA the journal Radio-Electronics carried some of the first home computer projects. Radio-Electronics had been founded in 1929 by Hugo Gernsback, the same man who gives his name to the most prestigious of the science fiction awards. Gernsback founded the magazine Amazing Stories in 1926,  and with his brother Sidney started the radio station WRNY in 1925. Gernsback is said to have coined the name Television in 1909 and WRNY was the first radio station to broadcast experimental television in 1928.



Britain too had a wealth of magazines devoted to radio, television and electronics. Amongst these were the Practical series, published by Frank Camm, brother of the aircraft designer Sydney Camm. The 1960s were, for the amateur, dominated by analogue electronics and numerous do it yourself projects were published that the enthusiast could build or at least study. I can recall one which was a copy of Gray Walters Turtle, an autonomous electronic device that was supposed to emulate animal behaviour by following light. Also notable was the monthly Wireless World. This journal carried numerous construction projects and notably carried, in 1945, Arthur Clarke's famous article where he described for the Communications Satellite. 

By 1970 the home computer was on its way and Radio-Electronics featured Don Lancasters TV Typewriter in 1973. (Not a computer but a how-brew video terminal which could display 16 lines of 32 character text on a standard TV.) The following year Radio-Electronics published a design for an 8 bit computer which the home enthusiast could build. But it was another USA magazine, Popular Electronics, just one year later, with its Altair 8800 really made an impact. The Altair was designed by a couple of enthusiast who had a small company making instrumentation kits for model rockets. MITS.



The Altair was based on an Intel 8080 microprocessor and as published could do very little. The computer I/O was a front panel with switches and lights. It was necessary to enter all programs, in binary, using the switches on the front panel. However, it was only a few months later when Microsoft's first product appeared,(written by Bill Gates and Paul Allen) a Basic interpreter for the Altair. With the Basic programming language the machine changed from being an engineering novelty to something that you could actually do something with. The homecomputer had arrived.

The popularity of the Altair pointed the way ahead. It did not take long for the homecomputer to lose its front panel and more neatly packaged machines such as the Apple and the Commodore Pet arrived. The core technology was the microprocessor, which in quantity was pretty cheap, but display systems and keyboards were expensive. The manufacturers went back to the hobbyist idea of using the TV as a  display and  borrowed from the hobbyists the cassette tape recorder  as bulk storage for programs.

Throughout the 1980s sales volumes increased and prices fell. The home computer market steadily grew. Computer games, word processing and eventually the first dialup bulletin boards appeared. The bulletin boards were precursors to the Internet. All of these developments started in the hands of the hobbyist. 

Having said all this, and watched as a few enthusiasts made big money out of riding the home computer wave, just what cutting edge technologies might todays hobbyists be working on? What will be the next big one? My money is on 3D printing. Today it's at just about the Altair 8800 stage of development. Kits are available and a core of enthusiasts world wide are learning how to use the technology. In common with all emerging technologies it borrows from connected, allied technologies such as the Internet, and 3D cad design. Most significantly much of the work is open source, being done altruistically by enthusiasts who are more keen on helping each other than trying to make money out of it. There are other emerging technologies, many of them, but this looks like the one that won't be dependent right from the start on big industry and big money. As such it may go places that no corporate executive could ever imagine. And that can only be a good thing.


The Social Consequences of Technological Change.


A few weeks ago I was thinking about what the theme for this blog should be. Over the last couple of years I've looked at books and films I like, bits of technology that interest me, and the lives of various people I admire. A bit of a mixture. 

I have an interest in science fiction and two of the novels I've written about deal with the changes imposed on people by technology. These pieces were, A Canticle for Leibwitz and Flowers for Algernon.  In the first the change is brought about by a devastating nuclear war which pushes civilisation back to the middle ages. In the second we have an amazing treatment that gives a mentally retarded man genius IQ. Essentially this concerns, In the event of new technology, then what do people do? This, for me, is the essence of science fiction. 

This is not generally the way history is written. While technical types may discuss  the esoterics  of technology, for example, how fitting drop tanks to the Luftwaffe fighter force at the time of the Battle of Britain might have effected the outcome of that conflict. Such matters do not generally feature in the history books. They will feature in this blog.

The blog will look at how changes in technology have effected society.  How technology changes society and how society changes technology will be matters for this blog.

Saturday, 29 January 2011

More essential music

Over recent years we have been witness to a breakdown of what was once a major industrial sector. The beast is not totally dead but it is in its final throes. This sector is the recorded music industry. 

As I've claimed earlier, music seems such a crucial part of our make up that we, as humans, will go to remarkable trouble to find ways of making and, now, reproducing music. The first part of the 20th Century was the time of mechanical music playing and the second part was the era of sound recording and reproduction.

In 1950 the vinyl record was introduced but it took a little while for it to really hit the big time. By the 1960s recorded music suddenly became a major industrial player and vast numbers of vinyl albums were sold to that newly empowered youth market. Music has always been a vital part of our leisure time, see elsewhere in this blog, http://terry-kidd.blogspot.com/2009/09/essential-music.html but the combination of the baby boomers reaching their teenage years, the invention of cheap vinyl LP records and cheap record players suddenly produced a big new industry. All that was needed was the right sort of product.

This new product came from America but got a British spin when bands like the Beatles created a genre with wide appeal to the new, teenage audience. Vinyl LP sales were such big business that the rock groups of the day spent, typically, a few weeks in a studio- if they were lucky, and then, when the album had been produced and was ready to hit the shops, several months on tour promoting it and generating sales.

The required infrastructure to manufacture albums, the pressing plant, packaging and distribution made companies such as EMI and Decca, previously better known for esoteric electronic systems, newly household names.

Although groups like the Beatles were popular enough to feature in a few low budget movies their main reason for being was to generate those album sales, everything else, the tours and the TV appearances were all in aid of promoting those sales. Admittance to rock concerts was relatively cheap, they were a promotional device for the albums.

But technology doesn't stand still and for the vinyl album the first big competitor was the compact cassette. Devised in the late 1960s by a company that was more interested in selling tape recorders than music, Philips. This new technology allowed copying of albums. Philips had devised a way to tame the magnetic tape deck by containing the twin spools and the loose tape ends within a plastic cassette. The quality was rather limited, on account of the narrow and slow speed tape but soon got better with improvements in tape technology and electronics. Strangely enough, the magnetic cassette soon became yet another way of selling pre-recoded music. The new cassettes were ideal for cars and the original perceived advantage, free home copying from existing media, was not hugely popular. Although there were a few enthusiasts who liked to compile tapes the loss in quality of an analogue to analogue copy and the copying time - a 45 minute album took 45 minutes to copy, all this seemed to discourage widespread copying. For home use the tapes had a disadvantage of albums, especially for short rock tracks, accessing a particular track required a lot of shuffling to find the start of a particular number. 

In any event, the record manufacturing industry fought back hard and introduced a new disc technology, the Compact Disc (mid 1980s), a technology that gave a significant quality improvement over the older analogue systems and the quick access to different songs that vinyl discs had given. Eventually it would also permitted home copying, but that would have to wait for another revolution, the home computer, but by then, for music reproduction, the CD itself had been superseded by a further technology. 

Bootleg CDs containing an artists' entire catalogue started appearing at what the British called 'Computer Fairs' in the early 1990s. These were meetings where you could shop for computer hardware and they existed for a brief time while the home PC was still mainly in the hands of the computer hobbyist. (The relationship between important new technology and the hobbyist is something I shall blog about on another day). Save to say that the Computer Fair provided a venue to bring together copyright thieves and their potential customers, and was largely ignored by the law. Later, of course, the internet would make these opportunists redundant but briefly they flourished.
  
The bootleg CDs were dependent on a new data compression system called MP3 and it was not long before it entered the legal mainstream with the introduction of the MP3 players. Falling prices for semiconductor storage and the introduction of  the IPOD made the manufacture of permanent media to carry music around on obsolete. With this has come the redundancy of the manufacturing infra structure.

Of course, the music industry still wants to make sales, even though the jobs that were once a part of the album manufacturing/distribution industry are long gone. Setups such as ITUNES are there to make music buying so convenient that finding a pirate version to copy is just too much trouble. Regardless of the long term fate of copyright the linkage between a physical object and particular music is long gone. 



Clearly, now, the marginal cost of reproducing the music is so tiny as to be barely measurable. In the 1960s record companies could point to their set-up and tooling costs as a means of justifying the prices charged. From a social point of view it was possible to point to the number of jobs produced by the business. 

The advertisements placed by the owners of copyright, the attempts to strike a parallel between illegal file copying and shoplifting are more than a little flawed. The resources that are displaced in order to copy a digital file are trivial. Moreover, the thief, should he choose to, can point to an actual reduction in environmental impact of the reproduction of a file copy compared to the manufacture and the manufacture and distribution of a legally produced disc. This knowledge will, I feel, in the long run remove the prejudice against so called copyright theft. 

Sony, who are the copyright owners of some of the greatest music of the twentieth century, are trying to hang on to their piece of the action, in the not too long run they will be joining the dinosaurs.

Changes have already come to the business model of the music industry. Rock music concerts still exist but they are no longer promotional vehicles for disc manufacturers. Nowadays concerts have to be revenue producers in their own right. 

But The Man, as 1970s hipsters were inclined to call big business, has lost his monopoly. With new technology all musicians and bands can distribute their music world wide.  Decca records rejected the Beatles, if EMI had done the same much of the soundtrack of the mid 20th century might not exist. These days there are numerous  opportunities to record and distribute music, anyone can do it - world wide. And in the long run this can only be a good thing.

Sunday, 17 October 2010

Technical Excellence

In the ‘swinging sixties’ Len Deighton wrote a best selling novel called the Ipcress File. This was filmed with Michael Caine who played Deighton’s working class spy hero. I love the Deighton spy genre but his best work, and one of the most meticulously researched of all books about Second World War aviation, is Deighton’s 1970 novel, Bomber.

When it was first published Bomber was a very large book. In 1970 most novels were around 250 pages and Bomber checked in at around 500 pages. The only thing comparable,back then, was the three volume version of Lord of the Rings. Deighton used a computer to create Bomber having seen an early form of word processor in use by IBM for creating their technical documentation. His previous works, it seems, had used scissors and Copydex and had been reworked using a literal copy and paste process and retyping. The increase in productivity that composing directly on a computer gave meant he could navigate around a huge book and manage the intricate, and as far as I can tell, technically accurate plot.


Bomber is about an RAF night bombing raid that goes hideously wrong. Not that this was unusual, night time navigation in WW2 and bomb aiming was a technical problem of considerable magnitude. Deighton understands this and goes to lengths to examine it within the context of the story.
        The whole plot revolves around an initial incident which causes the first target marker flares to be dropped too soon. The intended target is the German industrial city of Krefeld, but the bomber force actually attacks the small, fictional, market town of Altgarten. Altgarten has a large number of greenhouses. These show up on the radars of the bomber force as similar to the factory buildings of Krefeld. A further phenomena, creep back, draws the bulk of the bomb damage back across Altgarden.
       What Deighton is doing here, I believe, is illustrating just how imprecise the British night bombing effort was. He manages to do this without diminishing the efforts, courage and skills of the British crews. By 1943 it was known by Bomber Command how imprecise the vast bulk of the night bomber force could be. But, pre-war, Britain had invested hugely in the bomber force assuming that it would be an effective deterrent. It took a while before British High Command were prepared to concede how inaccurate the early attempts at night bombing were.

Deighton describes in intricate detail the workings of the German night fighter defence. How this system operated, and how well it exploited the shortcomings of the RAF’s aircraft is described superbly, and possibly for the first time in any non-classified, English language text.



The use of Schräge Musik (obliquely mounted) guns, and the technique of attacking the bomber force is described. The German night fighters were guided into the bomber stream by operators on the ground who are using powerful and accurate ground based radars. The nighfighters themselves had quite short range radars. They are directed by voice commands into a position behind and below the bomber stream.
       In this position the fighter pilots could often see the glow of the exhausts and sometimes see the target aircraft silhoueted against the sky. The Lancaster crews, who had poor visibilty below, were unlikely to spot the nightfighters. A ball turret gunner might have seen them, and these had been fitted on some marks of Lancaster, but were removed by the time that Deighton’s story was set.
       The German obliquely mounted guns, which no one on the British side anticipated, (despite the fact that similair guns had been used by the British in the first world war against Zepplins) allowed the fighters to gain a positive ID, get into the optimum position for destruction, and destroy a bomber with one burst.



In a world where some mainstream novels dump technical information straight out of wikipedia into the text, with often little understanding on the part of the writer, Deighton’s Bomber stands supreme. The accuracy and originality of the research, the clarity of the narrative, and the central part in the plot that the technology forms, illustrates that Deighton knows, and understands, exactly what it is he’s writing about.

From time to time there are rumours of a Bomber film. It’s been suggested that ‘Memphis Belle’ might have started out as an attempt to film Bomber. Certainly some of the book’s moments, most especially the ‘Opera House’ where the German defence system data is all collated on an illuminated plotting screen, would look astonishing on film.
       The close poximity of the groups of adversaries, who could sometimes hear each other on their common radio frequencies, suggest an intimacy like nothing any other soldiers have faced.
       The brushing contact, via invisible radar beams, at a time when television was a rich mans toy. Travel from England, to Germany and back again, when at the time only the wealthy knew of foreign travel, or even cars, these give the whole battle a remarkable, surealistic quality.

At the start the story opens with Sam Lambert, an NCO Lancaster pilot who is trying to be persuaded to participate in a cricket match by his unit commander. On the weekend in question Sam has other plans.
   Sam Lambert is a decent man. He's trying to serve his country. He flies to Germany by night and encounters people who want to kill him. By day he is caught up in the mess of unit politics. In a sense he is just like one of Deighton’s espionage heros.

Sunday, 26 September 2010

Template for Terror

The tiny towns are pastel plaster like a modern watercolor of a medieval memory. With mastery of image Lee Miller conjures a version of the vision and the mythical truth that it is meant to depict. The line applies as much to the town of Dachau as to any other Bavarian town. Yet the word Dachau invokes many other images. The conentration camp memorial there is something that I’ve never quite had the courage to see. Recently a friend from England came to visit and together we went to the place.


Dachau was the site of the first of the concentration camps, opened in 1933 and intended for political prisoners, which is to say, those who opposed the Nazi regime. The burning of the Berlin Reichstag building in 27 February 1933 was used as an opportunity to introduce new laws which suspended civil liberties for Germans. Dachau was opened a few weeks afterwards.



The prison at Dachau was intended to be a showpiece of the Nazi regime. In the 1930's foreign dignitaries visiting Germany were brought here to visit to be impressed by its beauty and its facilities. The arrangements, from the entry gate with its Work Makes Free, dictum, to the tree lined esplanade were intended to give an impression of humanity and the promise of rehabilitation. In reality the trees lined the route to the cemetery and the only freedom to be found was after being worked to death.





Dachau was never an extermination camp. The Nazis kept those outside Germany. Yet, over 32,000 died at Dachau. Dachau was a prototypical business centre for the Nazi regime. A template for other camps and a source of income. Prisoners who were fit enough to work were employed within the camp or travelled to work in nearby factories. Companies such as BMW and Siemens all hired manpower at bargain prices in the form of those inmates who were fit enough, and suited enough, to the work.


Dachau’s ‘hospital’ was used for various experiments on prisoners. Tests on behalf of the Luftwaffe recorded the time a person, in normal flying gear, could survive in freezing water. Decompression experiments, where live prisoners were subject to abrupt pressure drops, were also carried out.


The euphemism, human resources was never applied so completely as at Dachau. The prisoners were exploited in every way imaginable. Once a prisoner had become too sick to work they were registered as ‘Invalid’ and then executed. In the doublethink logic of Dachau the ‘Invalids’ were deemed beyond rehabilitation. Everything possible was taken from them, each prisoner’s ‘medical’ record notes if they had gold fillings or crowns so that these could later be recovered from the bodies.

The brickwork of the crematorium at Dachau shows a roughness unlike typical German masonry. It was built by slave labour and quickly, and yet the design shows the usual attention to detail and efficiency.

Prisoners entered the building at one end via narrow rooms with overhead pipes where their clothes were hung. Soon, their clothes would be reused by others. Then they entered the ‘shower room’ and the door closed behind them.




This picture shows the exterior of the shower room. The chemical Zyklon B was poured into the cast iron chutes. Between the two chutes, the vertical rectangle, was an armoured glass panel where the condition of the prisoners could be monitored. Death could take up to twenty minutes. Afterwards a ventilation system cleared the room and the bodies were moved either to the ovens or to adjacent storage.




Many of us have some notion of prison life which includes a plucky group of prisoners outwitting the guards and maintaining a sense of dignity. This was not the case at Dachau. The administrators had planned for that and had a system which of all the things at Dachau strikes me has the most ingenious, and the most invidious.




The picture shows part of the Memorial of Badges, one of several artworks which are in place in the camp. These show the different markers that the prisoners wore on their uniforms. We all recognise the Star of David but there were many prisoner badges whih indicated a position within a catalogue of groups. The groups became a hierarchy of privilege and punishment.


The German hardened criminals wore green triangles. Red triangles were worn by the Communists, Social Democrats and other political prisoners, and blue by the foreign workers.  Homosexuals wore pink triangles. There were Brown badges for the Gypsies and Jehovah's Witnesses wore a purple triangle. A bar over the top of the triangle meant that an inmate was a second-timer, or a prisoner who had served time in the camp, been released, and had then been arrested again. The Jews always wore two triangles with a yellow triangle on top of another colour, usually red which signified a political prisoner.


The hierarchy always placed the Jews at the bottom, with the gypsies immediately above them, and then raising, through some subtle league table, the other groups up to the most privileged and powerful, the green triangles - the hardened criminals. As a result everyone knew who they were and where they were in the pecking order.


With this ‘chain of command’ the SS, who ran the camp, were able to maintain discipline with the minimum of guards. Privileges, and extra rations were handed out to the people at the top of the prisoner hierarchy. These used their power to maintain order.




In the years after the war the camp at Dachau was used for emergency accomodation and with the post war rebuilding the Bavarian government came under pressure to clear the site. This was resisted and over the years the site has been reconstructed in certain areas in accordance with the photographs and the records the SS kept.

At the end Dachau is exactly what it was first intended to be, a showpiece for a regime. A regime which generated terror on an unprecedented scale. 

Sunday, 5 September 2010

Lee Miller

Lee Miller was born in 1907 and in her 70 years she was many things: a model, a debutant, a muse, a writer, a photographer, an actress, a mother and a gourmet cook.

To do justice to her life would take a dozen blogs. This is about her time as the world's first female war correspondent.  Lee Miller spent the days after D Day following the US Army as a war correspondent and photographer. Her work, which first appeared in the magazine Vogue, contain many memorable images. Arguably, they have shaped our view of the Second World War and have been the guide track for a dozen war movies.



Lee’s first piece as the Vogue war correspondent was about the 44th Evac, a canvas field hospital where emergency patch up surgery was carried out on wounded troops prior to their dispatch, away from the front, to England. Lee’s images of surgery in progress, captured in her photographs and text, with masked, gowned medics engaged over the bodies of soldiers set the style for the M*A*S*H film and TV show.


Next Lee moved on to St Malo and recorded what was, in the grand scheme of things, a rather minor military action. A German strong hold is being dug out the hard way by the 83rd Division. By accident Lee  finds herself in the thick of it.  Our long-range artillery was etching arcs of sound over my head. It was a temptation to look up each time at these invisible sphere-songs with their trailing rattle. Finally they went crash into the citadel and there would be a salvo from there answering back. I hung around waiting to latch onto someone who would be going somewhere or doing something and would take me. A tank destroyer on caterpillar tracks moved down the street next to us and set up for business. It shed wiremen as it went. Telephonists squatted in the street and the gun belched at the forts. In a very few minutes the enemy counter-battery zeroed in on it with 88s. They went whistle bang whistle bang whistle bang, and broke in the trees, the roofs, the street. The boys on the gun didn’t pay any attention but since I had no business being there anyway I went back to the villa which was only a bit better than the street.




In Lee’s pictures we discover that the war was not exclusively populated by men. There are nurses, naturally, and Russian women soldiers. And there are women who had made the wrong choice and become lovers of the Germans and who were now punished by their neighbours.


There are pictures of Parisian girls flirting with the GIs, and one can only hope that some of them made good on the promise of their pretty smiles. In Lee's writing there is a sense of reality that is missing from contemporary coy British accounts of soldiers and their preoccupations. As Lee puts it, ‘Anyone who has found a pair of girl’s pants for his helmet is envied’. And she has an eye for technical detail, she knows that the artillery needs Observation Points and telephone communications. So the communications boys, as well as the spotters and gunners, get a credit.

Next up is Paris, which Lee knew well from her earlier life and she got to meet some old friends.


Lee and Picasso

Keeping in mind that all this was for Vogue, a magazine about fashion and lifestyle, Lee writes about how Paris style has changed to accommodate the wartime condition.  It’s amazing, after reading about relentless total war, blitz and counter-blitz, and the horrors of the eastern front that 12 weeks after the liberation of Paris Lee had a an actual fashion show to report on.  More remarkable still was a Bitch-a-gram from Vogue head office criticising the quality of the ‘snapshots’ that Lee was sending back, Vogue expected studio posed shots featuring models of refinement!

Lee Miller was as patriotic as Patton but she still found room for some left wing sensibility. Her rationalisation of the roots of Naziism is terse and cuts to the heart of the matter, she speaks of the supporters of Hitler. The type of person who clips his share coupons or reads the ticker tape for marketing profits without asking if the mine is a swindle or the dividends drawn from capital lived there. They bought Hitler on the same terms and they are very shocked to find themselves the ‘widows and orphans’ of a bucket shop scheme. They expect sympathy from us for their having been accomplices of crooks and receivers of stolen goods. 

At Ecternach, on the Luxemburg border with Germany. Lunch is brought abruptly to a halt a few times by Buzzbombs, (V1 Flying Bombs) passing over the building, grinding and changing their lousy gears. They sounded like the death rattles here already. I tried to calculate the ‘something’ divided or multiplied by ‘time’ equals ‘something else’- when you’d be getting it in London, and the little hairs on the back of my neck stood at attention while I auralized the thud and crump of that unbrained monster in Pimlico or Hampstead. In fact, by now the allied advance was such that those early cruise missiles no longer had the range for London, the war was coming to an end.



Lee followed the Army on into Germany. She was a stunning Aryan beauty, usually smoking a cigarette, and wearing a hodge podge of military and civilian clothes. She had a jeep, a camera, a typewriter and a four gallon can into which all the whisky, gin vodka she'd managed to ‘liberate’ was poured.  She was having a whale of a time, but then came Buchenwald and Dachau.



In this case (Dachau) the camp is so close to the town that there is no question about the inhabitants knowing what went on. The railway siding into the camp runs past quite a few swell villas and the last train of dead and semi dead deportees was long enough to extend past them. The cars are still full of skeletal dead, and the path beside the trains are littered with the fleshless bodies of those who tried to get out and walk to their execution.

One of Lee’s pictures shows a couple of grim faced, middle aged German ladies.  One might have worked in a local beer garden while the other could be anyones mother. They’ve been brought, by orders of General Patton, to bear witness to the horrors of the concentration camp at Buchenwald. In Lee's photograph there is a black American GI in the foreground. It's something of a set-up, Lee's vision of how the society of plurality became the victors while the society that aspired to racial purity was defeated.



Lee made it to Hitler’s house in Munich. By now her hatred of all things ‘Kraut’ was relentless and she mocks  Hitler’s taste.  The bookcase that jutted out into the room had as savage an angle as the swastika itself. The art work – sculpture, still wearing prize medals from exhibitions on a string – was mediocre as were the paintings on the walls. I hoped to find one of the masters (Hitler's) own works. There was a plaster cast of Hitler’s hands, and on the desk in the next section of the room a globe of the world. The piano, a Bechstein, was out of tune but the radio was a masterpiece. In the main entrance were cupboards holding crystal and china, linen and silver, all swastika’d and initialled A.H. There was a rubber plant and a black plaster eagle with folded wings.

This is where Lee’s most famous picture was taken, soaping the back of her neck in Hitler’s bath tub. Perched on the side of the bath is a photograph of the Fuehrer, and discharging what seems to be most of the mud they’ve collected since her time at 44th Evac, Lee’s army boots on Hitler’s bathmat.





Finally, Lee finds the Germans baffling.
The tiny towns are pastel plaster like a modern watercolour of a medieval memory. Little girls in white dresses and garlands promenade for their first communion. The children have stilts and marbles, and tops and hoops, and they play with dolls. Mothers sew and sweep and bake, and farmers plow and harrow. ... I’m just like the soldiers here, who look at the beautiful countryside, use the super modern comforts of their buildings and wonder why the Germans wanted anything more.

After the war Lee, at the age of 40, became a mother. As a result of her war experiences she suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder. Yet she would never again find as great a subject as the war. What peacetime assignment could compare? Lee was damaged by what she’d seen. However, there could have been only one thing worse than taking a job such as this, and that would have been not taking it.


Saturday, 28 August 2010

A Long Chain

Some things you remember all your life, like the news of some totally impossible, totally unexpected event - the death of JFK, the events of 9/11, and, on the 28th of January, 1986, the loss of the space shuttle Challenger.

At the time images of the shuttle were everywhere. Nikolodium, one of the brand new cable TV channels, a channel for children, had a Space Shuttle animation running during all its program breaks. The Space Shuttle was shorthand for all of the USA’s competencies in technology, organisational skills and wealth.

I was in one of the engineering labs at Boeing Huntsville when I heard the news. The phone rang and one of my colleagues answered. I can remember fragments of the conversation. Dick Peterson was asking, “But what happened to the shuttle?” He put the phone down and said that there’d been some kind of explosion during the launch, there was no sign of the shuttle. His wife and child had been watching it on live TV and had called to tell what they’d seen. They wanted to know immediatly how such an impossible event could have happened.

In those days, even if we had a few computers on our desks we had no internet and I imagine we immediately went in search of a radio, or went home. This disaster, unlike the Apollo 13 which had been so memorably rescued, was over with the crew apparently killed instantly.


It was assumed at the time, ‘The Shuttle blew up’, in fact it did not. Hot gases from the right hand solid fuel booster leaked past a rubber ‘o’ ring seal. Eventually they burned through the aft part of the large orange hydrogen/oxygen ‘external tank’ which the shuttle orbiter, (the delta winged spaceplane which goes to orbit and glides back to earth) is attached to. A few seconds later the right hand solid rocket booster broke away at its aft securing point, then the ‘external tank’ broke up. Abruptly, at 48,000 ft, the orbiter was tossed around and subjected to 20g forces that caused it to break up.

What happened to the crew next, during the time it took the crew compartment to come back down, is a matter of conjecture. One wing was torn from the orbiter almost immediately. The intact crew cabin broke free and continued to ascend, to 65,000 ft. After the break up the crew were in free-fall and there are indications that at least some of them were still alive. The reserve oxygen tanks show depletion of two and a half minutes of oxygen, the time from the event until the crew cabin hit the ocean with a force of 200G.


Theoretical physicist Richard Feynman was drafted into the Rogers Commission on the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster. He was an unusual choice, but whoever nominated him showed good judgement. Feynman’s conclusions on system reliability and the gap between the expectations of management and engineering reality are on target and have a wide application.

Feynman was one of a number of American scientists that had been on the Manhattan project to develop the atomic bomb. In later life he would recall his time at Los Almos as a time when things were organised extraordinarily well. His views of NASA were very different. Feynman’s findings led to the three year halt in shuttle flights during which NASA went through widespread reorganisation.

The head of the Rogers Commission to investigate the Shuttle disaster described him thus, "Feynman is becoming a real pain." Yet Feynman, with no small assistance from another commision member, Air Force General Donald Kutyna, memorably revealled the cause of the disaster on live TV. Feynman also threatened to remove his name from the Rogers Commision official report unless he was allowed to add his own appendix which described a number of further risk areas which could be potential safety issues for subsequent flights.

Despite NASA’s official position, pre-Challenger, that the complete shuttle was extremely safe a large number of NASA engineers felt that the risk of a launch failure was between 1 in 50 and 1 in a 100. Challenger was its 10th flight, (and the 25th shuttle flight overall). On the day of the launch the very cold conditions were far from ideal.

The issue, as Feynman demonstrated on TV with a cup of iced water, a clamp and some of the rubber o ring material was that in very cold conditions, as these were, the rubber became stiff and would not recover its shape fast enough to maintain a seal.


There might be a few who would see Feynman’s on-screen revelation as grandstanding. Maybe a little, yet Feynman was smart enough to fully understand the problem, he had the tenacity to dig deep to the bottom of it and he had the balls to go public with it.

Donald Kutyna, no slouch at digging to the bottom of problems for the Air Force, arguably used Feynman. He told Feynman about he'd been repairing his car and discovered that some carburettor seals were ineffective due to low temperatures on a cold morning. Feynman latched onto this and related it to the o ring seals on the shuttle. Maybe he thought Feynman’s approach would get the point across more effectivly than his own.


Kutyna, even before coming to the Roger’s Commision already knew plenty about the Shuttle, and NASA’s organisation. He’d been in charge of setting up Vandenberg Air Force’s shuttle launch facility. Vandenberg was never actually used for launching the shuttle because of the Challenger disaster. Kutyna, himself not one for mincing words, said that NASA allowing the Challenger launch, under those conditions, was akin to an airline allowing a plane to fly despite evidence that one of its wings was about to fall off.

Feynman and Kutyna made an excellent team and Feynman went on to add his appendix to the Roger’s Commision report which can be read here. http://www.ralentz.com/old/space/feynman-report.html

Feynman’s section opens thus, It appears that there are enormous differences of opinion as to the probability of a failure with loss of vehicle and of human life. ... The higher figures come from the working engineers, and the very low figures from management...quoting NASA’s official line... "the probability of mission success is necessarily very close to 1.0." It is not very clear what this phrase means, asks Feynman, Does it mean it is close to 1 or that it ought to be close to 1? This rhetoric is how NASA management deluded themselves into overlooking the alarms and cautions that their own engineers were raising.

Feynman’s section looks at a few other aspects as well. The shuttle had, by the standards of the 1980’s, a large amount of safety critical software running on it. He says about 250,000 lines of code in its entirety. (By current aircraft standards no more than one major subsystem.)

Feynman is complimentary of the software production process. First, having described all the very labour intensive methods of classic safety critical software testing, he adds, ...there is an independent verification group, that takes an adversary attitude to the software development group, and tests and verifies the software as if it were a customer of the delivered product.... the computer software checking system and attitude is of the highest quality.

However, in a word of caution he says, (although) there appears to be no process of gradually fooling oneself while degrading standards so characteristic of the Solid Rocket Booster .... To be sure, there have been recent suggestions by management to curtail such elaborate and expensive tests as being unnecessary at this late date in Shuttle history.

Three years later, and after much redesign and reorganisation, the Shuttle flew again.

17 years on, another shuttle, Columbia was lost during a re-entry accident. This on the 113th shuttle launch. But by now no one was pretending that the shuttle was as safe as a commercial airliner. Or was pretending that after fixing one weak link in a long chain that somehow the entire chain had been strengthened. As Feynman put it, When playing Russian roulette the fact that the first shot got off safely is little comfort for the next.