Wednesday, 7 April 2010

Eric Brown. The world's greatest test pilot

It’s about thirty years since the writer Tom Wolfe rather breathlessly revealed that, in addition to the well known ‘celebrity’ astronauts of the American space program, there were a whole bunch of people doing important work who were called engineering test pilots. Their achievements were every bit as important as the Apollo astronauts yet nobody knew their names. Nobody outside of aviation that is.



It happens that not all those great test pilots were American. Eric ‘Winkle’ Brown, a Scot borne in 1919, is one of the most remarkable of them all. For a country that gives out knighthoods for reading the television news the fact that Britain has not made more of Brown’s achievements is astonishing. Still in full possession of his wits, and wit, at 91 Brown’s work has covered the most exciting years of aviation - the period from 1940 to the Apollo landings in 1969.

Eric holds the world record of having flown the largest number of different aircraft types - 487. And he was the first to land a jet aircraft on a carrier.  In the closing months of the war he flew several advanced, (which is to say bloody tricky) German aircraft back to Britain. With an MA in German he was ideally suited to fly these and then he was in the front line of examining and analysing German secret research.

The following interview, conducted by the former BBC science correspondent Reginald Turnhill and including astronauts Joe Engle and George Abbey gives a fascinating glimpse of the times.

Top Test Pilots Discussion

It’s very hard not to be astonished by the German wartime achievements. Brown describes how they were way ahead of the Allies in virtually every aspect of aviation engineering with the possible exception of electronics. Brown describes the remarkable Me163 rocket plane. He was the only non-German to fly it under rocket power.


Also discussed is the almost forgotten Space Shuttle precursor, the X20 Dyna-Soar. This single seat, vertical launched craft would have landed conventionally after re-entering from Earth orbit. This was a fabulous road not taken in space exploration. With a genealogy going back to World War 2, Sanger’s proposed design for a German bomber capable of attacking the USA, the Dyna-Soar would have made an astonishing weapons systems.


Brown speaks of Concorde, the supersonic transport, generally noted for being British/French, but also with its roots in German wartime research.



I’d love to write more about Eric Brown, but I’m without my prime reference. I keep buying his biography, Wings on my Sleeve, then lending it to people and never getting it back. It’s recommended.



Wings on My Sleeve
X-20 Dyna-Soar
America Bomber

Sunday, 21 February 2010

Triumph of the Geeks

 Up Pixar


In this movie, now out on DVD, Pixar bring together three outsiders.

The movie opens with the Carl Fredrikson, a boy of eight who meets the girl who will become the love of his life. Ellie and Carl are made for each, Carl is shy and nervous while Ellie is exuberant and extrovert. She recognises in Carl her soul mate and they marry and grow old together. And so the story begins.

Ellie dies and Carl is left a lonely, bitter widower who regrets that he and Ellie never took a trip they’d long dreamed of, to Venezuela in the footsteps of their hero Charles Muntz. Now Carl is besieged on all sides by urban development but refuses to leave the house that contains all the memories of his earlier life. After an unfortunate accident Carl decides to go, and take his memories with him. He fastens thousands of helium balloons to the house and makes a break for it just as the men from the retirement home are about to take him.

Unbeknownst to Carl, a plump, accident prone eight year old boy called Russell has stowed away on the house. Despite Carl’s wishes they both get swept away to Venezuela. Now that he’s got there it is Carl’s wish that he position the house by Paradise Falls, where Ellie had always imagined it, and he coops Russell to help him.

Along the way they meet another outsider, a talking dog called Dug. They befriend a brilliantly coloured flightless bird called Kevin, and encounter Carl’s old hero Charles Muntz. Muntz is now the premier bad guy with a dirigible and a pack of talking dogs. They are Dug’s old pack who have shunned him. Muntz is obsessed with capturing Kevin and he believes that Carl is after the bird himself and this makes him an enemy.

Now the action starts with Kevin taken on board the airship and Russell determined to free him. Carl gets the house airborne and takes off after Russell. Muntz launches a trio of biplanes (piloted by dogs) from the dirigible and they attempt to shoot the house down. Russell outsmarts the dogs and frees Kevin and in the final battle Muntz falls to his doom leaving Russell, Carl and Dug victorious.

Listening to the words of the artists at Pixar, it’s hard not to see them as one time geeks. They were the loner kids who wrote, painted, maybe even made model aeroplanes while the non-geeks played sports and ran with the pack. They were the odd balls, the ones who didn’t join in, the ones to be pitied. These are the kids who grew up to make a fabulous, memorable piece of art, on the cutting edge of computer technology yet with its roots deep in the emotional style of Capra.

Good going geeks.

Wednesday, 17 February 2010

Flowers for Algernon

I was re-reading Flowers for Algernon the other day, and as I did, I recalled how the first reading of it affected me, and how it defined what I thought was special about science fiction. For me the tale is one of the all time greats, in addition it holds, I think, a useful tip for aspiring writers.


Since its first publication in 1958 it has been remade in movie, TV and theatrical form many times, and through these forms it has gained admittance to the mainstream, but it is still essentially a SF story. For me an SF story includes a fictional piece of science as an implicit part of the plot. In this case the premise is that a special surgical technique has greatly increased the intelligence of Charley Gorden. We learn nothing about the procedure beyond the fact that Charley's IQ is hugely increased. This doesn't matter. For me this model serves as a working definition for Science Fiction:  IF [insert technological breakthrough here], THEN what will humans do?

In Flowers we go with Charley as incredible changes to his intellect occur. When the original short story was written such matters as IQ and other forms of pysch. testing were considered to be preminent, defining characteristics ofhumans. Yet one of the key points of the story is, as far as Charley is concerned, that despite the changes to his intelligence an essential part of him is maintained across the arc of the narrative.

Some people give the following definition of a story: Get a character in a situation, then throw rocks at him. This is the template for Flowers. At the start Charley is a moron who is the butt of the jokes of his co-workers. At the middle he is a lonely genius who has discovered that his brilliance will soon fade. At the end he has lost everything, his love and his intellect. The only thing he has managed to hold on to is the cloudy recollection that he was once smart. And throughout his journey, even at the heights when he was hailed a genius, he still maintains a connection with, and feels ashamed for his former self,


Finally Charley losses almost everything. All Charley has left is his kinship with Algernon the white lab mouse who has made the same journey. Charley knows he has a connection with Algernon, but he no longer understands why. We might be left wondering what the whole point was. Charley has gained no insight, he can't even recall how much he actually had and lost. Yet Keyes delivers the payoff through the minor characters. After everything, when Charley returns to his old job, we discover that his old tormentors, who can recall his travails better than he can, finally show some respect for him. It's a blink and you'd miss it moment, but for me it's crucial.

When Keyes submitted the story to Galaxy the editor said he loved it but please re-write it to allow Charley to hold on to his intelligence. Keyes left the story unchanged and went to another magazine. Later, after the short story version had found success Keyes developed it into a novel. Again various publishers asked for a rewrite so that Charley could retain his gifts. Keyes eventually found a publisher who would go with the story as we find it today. I don't think anyone could doubt that Keyes was correct. Had he changed it he might have made a quicker sale but he would have created just another SF potboiler, notable only for a little physcho babble about ink blot tests. Instead he created a classic that has never been out of print, sold over five million copies and, fifty years on been retold on stage and screen over a dozen times.

Sometimes, it seems, it just pays to stick to your guns.

Wednesday, 6 January 2010

An Enduring Myth

There is a cherished notion, held close by UK aviation enthusiasts, that Britain, at the end of World War 2, had an aviation industry that was second to none and was only prevented from capitalising on it by the self serving attitudes of trade unions (supported by the Labour party) and the short sightedness of governments, (also Labour) who toyed with the industry and spitefully prevented it from developing numerous world beating aircraft.


See:
TSR2 Online
Wiki on TSR2
Cancelled projects
TSR2


The reality of it is rather different as the parliamentary record of the day, Hansard shows. Sir William Robson Brown (Conservative) in the parliamentary debate on the 1966 Plowden report on the British aircraft industry made the following statement:
“Production costs in the (British aircraft) industry  are something which I cannot comprehend. With wage costs 40 to 50 per cent. lower than they are in the United States, our manpower production costs are 2½ times higher.”

Now it was customary in debates on British industrial productivity, in the days when industrial productivity played a significant part in the British economy, to demonise the unions, but that’s only part of the story. In order to see why British production costs were so high, compared to the USA and other countries, we have to go back to 1798 and Eli Whitney.

The concept of interchangeable parts is often credited to Whitney. Although historians are still debating who actually came up with it, this concept, the American_system_of_manufacturing  is defined as a way of using standardised, identical, interchangeable parts, manufactured to a consistent tolerance. Interchangeable parts were a turning point in industrialisation. Prior to this all manufactured items had been the work of skilled craftsmen making bespoke articles and the parts and pieces were usually anything but interchangeable.

With the invention of the automobile American manufacturers quickly embraced interchangeable parts. Henry Ford was proud to proclaim that no files were used on his production line, all the parts fitted perfectly, and were interchangeable. This had the further advantage that spare parts could just bolt in, again without rework.

However, there are significant initial costs in mass production, drawings have to be very carefully prepared with all dimensions and tolerances specified in great detail, and components made to much higher tolerances if they are to be quickly assembled without rework. Often tooling, parts which must be manufactured in order to manufacture and form other parts, must also be made. Consequently the start up costs are much higher.

In Britain cars were seen as the costly playthings of the wealthy volume manufacture was not anticipated, and the American approach did not find favour. The resultant high unit costs made this a self fulfilling prophecy and in Britain making cars in high volume took ages to catch on.


So, while 1930s Germany was stamping out the first Beetles priced so that workers could drive them on the new autobahns, the British car manufacturers remained proudly elitist and held on to methods which called for a level of ‘fitting’ during assembly. This approach was presented as a virtue, the low volume luxury car makers held that their cars were built by craftsmen  and this was promoted as exclusivity.

The British aircraft industry of the 1930s worked in a very similar way to its car manufacturers. And, borrowing the rational, they held that skilled fitters were essential whenever airframes and aero engines had to be manufactured. When the war was imminent and the British government wanted to increase aircraft production big problems were encountered when experienced mass producers attempted to adopt the aircraft industries' drawings and processes. Even relatively straight forward sub-assemblies such as bomb racks, when sent out to be manufactured by manufacturers such as Hoover and Electrolux, created problems. The supplied drawings were not always complete and tolerances were insufficient to define parts that could be assembled without extensive hand rework. The subcontractors ended up redrawing the original blueprints produced by the aviation big boys such as Avro and Handley Page to the standards that were customary in vacuum cleaner manufacture.

Even the drawings of the famous Rolls Royce Merlin engine, which was eventually manufactured in in huge quantities, had to be extensively reworked for volume production.  Engineers from the Ford Motor company told Rolls Royce that their tolerances were too wide for volume production.  Over 20,000 Rolls Royce drawings had to be redrawn, over a year, to meet the production methods of the volume car manufacturer. As a result the man hours to produce a Merlin engine fell from 10,000 to under 3,000. Rolls-Royce_Merlin

This is not to say that the designs of the Merlin and aircraft like the Spitfire were flawed, aerodynamically they were not, but the manufacturing depended on skilled fitters who carried much of the design and production process in their heads and knowing how to bend, hammer and file the components to fit. This had a big effect on productivity. The German Messerschmidt 109 took about 4,000 man hours to manufacture compared  to 14,000 man hours for a Spitfire. You’ll probably find people who’ll tell you the Spitfire was a better plane but I doubt that even the most rabid fan will claim that each Spitfire was worth three 109s, and, as Stalin put it, Quantity has a quality all of its own.


When the war ended Britain was left with a huge and experienced aircraft industry. It had priceless experience in the new field of jet propulsion and privileged access to German wartime research. Yet the manufacturing techniques hadn’t changed much. The English Electric Canberra impressed the United States Air Force to the extent that they subcontracted the American Martin aircraft company to produce them under license. The US built aircraft was called the B57 and with this design Martin found that all the British drawings had to be reworked before the aircraft could be manufactured. Despite the lessons from Ford and the other volume manufacturers, for the British aircraft industry there just wasn’t an incentive to change. The industry had spent the war years on  cost plus work with the government as the only customer. Higher costs actually meant higher profits and this was a disincentive to spend money on tooling and up front engineering.

Huge and fragmented, Britain’s post war aircraft industry lost ground while the American industry went from strength to strength. The British Comet, the worlds first jet airliner, was hit by a series of accidents attributed to a design error in the windows of the pressurised cabin. Yet what startled Americans when they visited the Comet factory in Hatfield were the production methods. The Boeing visitors thought they would spend more on tooling for a one off prototype than the British were using on the production line.

In a bid to try and snatch back a technical lead Britain joined with France to make the supersonic airliner Concorde. Major aircraft assemblies had to be produced in Britain and France and they had to fit together precisely. Finally the British aircraft industry had to produce drawings and processes to completely define what was to be made, no longer could craftsmen sort things out on the shop floor - everything had to fit first time. As the sixties continued more multinational projects were started, the Jaguar, Tornado and the various civil Airbus types. The legacy of Concorde was to force the British aircraft industry to reach beyond cottage industry manufacturing and work at world class levels. It took a while, and in the early days of the joint Italian, German and British Tornado it was the British manufactured parts of the work share that had fitting problems. But Britain only caught up as the bar was being set still higher. All the big American aerospace companies were engaged in Apollo project, subsequently the best in the world got immensely better.

In more recent times much of what remains of the British aircraft industry has been engaged building the Nimrod MRA4. This is a rework of an earlier aircraft which itself was derived from that 1960s Comet airliner. This project has now cost the UK tax payer £3.6 Billion, for nine aircraft. For reasons that probably seemed like a very good idea at the time, only about 80% of the airframe is brand new, with sections of the airframe inherited from the 1960s build. This has caused some of the huge overspend. The legacy airframe components were difficult to integrate with the new build elements and they give an insight into just how bad the older generation aircraft were. There were differences of up to 4 inches in length between parts of the legacy fuselage components. By comparison, for the Boeing B777, which first flew 15 years ago, Boeing claim each aircraft to be within 3/100th of an inch of each other over a fuselage length of 200 feet.
Nimrod Lewis Page     Boeing

The American system of manufacture really started something, at least in mechanical engineering. There are those who maintain that software engineering has yet to reach the same formal level. Much of the industry is still dependent on skilled craftsman carrying the design in their heads. But not, at least, in the aircraft industry. Software for use in aircraft systems IS subject to formal controls and rigorous testing. Formal engineering methods are imposed on the industry for safeties sake, and this is largely thanks to the American FAA who set the standards, effectively world wide. Software standards tend to be imposed by brute force testing methods more exhaustive than scientific. Perhaps it will take another major initiative like the Manhattan project or Project Apollo, before true software engineering becomes a reality but at least there are parts of the industry moving in the right direction.

Sunday, 20 December 2009

Analog Computers

In her excellent book, Longitude.  Dava Sobel told how a clock behaving in a deterministic way is a crucial component of successful navigation. The first accurate clock which could maintain synchronisation with the time at zero degrees longitude was the beginnings of an analogue navigation computer, albeit one that needed a little manual assistance to complete its task.

What makes an analogue? An old style vinyl album records a representation of the sound waves that took place when the original piece was recorded. A frozen graph of the sound that’s been curved into a spiral from the outside to the centre of the record. The volume level of the sound is represented by the depth of the peaks and troughs of the graph, and the pitch by the interval between the peeks and troughs. Low volume sounds tend to be hard to distinguish from imperfections in the manufacture of the disk - noise. The primary characteristic of analogue systems, and their main limitations: the magnitude of all values is represented by the magnitude of a signal somewhere.



The schematic above shows the Moniac analogue computer. (currently on display in the Science Museum in London.) It was used as a teaching aid to model the national economy. Moniac used the flow of water through the system to 'model' an economy. It featured valves to create the effect of changes in taxation and other policy decisions. See Monica technical description for a complete article.


Analogue computers used in gunnery and navigation need to be built like the proverbial brick outhouse. They generally used gears and motors. Again physical values are used with, for example, the distance turned by a wheel representing values such as speed or distance.

A number of mathematical functions must be performed and over the years engineers have dreamt up different ways of performing them. A classic problem in air navigation is distance travelled over ground when all we know is airspeed and direction. Before we get very far we need to do a little Polar to Cartesian conversion. If airspeed is known, and heading, how can we get distance travelled north and south, east and west?

One answer was the ball resolver, see below. Essentially it is an infinitely variable gear. (This is actually from an early 20th century computer in the Science Museum for predicting tides but the same mechanism in somewhat miniaturised form featured in many navigation computers.)



An electric motor turns the disc at a speed that represents airspeed. The disc turns the brass ball and the ball turns the roller. If the ball is positioned at the outside of the disc the roller will turn quickly, if the ball is moved towards the middle of the disc it will turn the roller progressively slower.

The system has another motor, this driven when the aircraft heading changes. This motor moves the ball from side to side. When the plane is flying due north the ball is positioned at the outside of the disc. The roller is turning at it’s highest possible speed for the speed of the disc. If the aircraft turns to the right and flies more east, as in the diagram below, the system will move the roller towards the centre of the disc. Even with the airspeed the same the velocity north will reduce.

A second resolver is used to calculate velocity east. Identical to the north one except that the ball is set up to move differently. With this one the ball is at the outside of the disc when we are flying east and at the inside when we are flying north.

With the two revolvers we can convert the polar parameter airspeed and heading to the cartesian velocity north and velocity east. And velocity north goes negative when the aircraft is flying south and velocity east goes negative it is going west.  (and, BTW those same resolvers can work the trick backwards and convert Cartesian back to Polar.)

With the velocities it’s pretty easy to calculate distance travelled. Those mechanical counters on bikes and speedometers integrate speed and get distance. It’s just a matter of gearing. If we’ve decided that 60 miles an hour is represented by 60 revolutions per minute we just have to arrange the gearing so that one mile will pop up after 60 revolutions of the velocity rollers.

We can even turn distance in miles into degrees of Latitude and Longitude. 60 nautical mile is one degree of Latitude, but Longitude is a little more tricky. Those pesky lines of Longitude get closer together as we move away from the equator so a third disc resolver needs to be added to correct the velocity East/Longitude, for changes in Latitude.

Of course, these calculations assume no wind conditions, unlikely. But supposing we have a system that can measure groundspeed and drift. Moving on a few years from the Norden bombsight etc (which needed ground observation to get drift) we had aircraft like the Vulcan with downwards looking doppler radar that could directly measure groundspeed and drift. So, instead of feeding the computer airspeed we feed it groundspeed derived from radar, Green Satin.




Green Satin  also supplies the drift angle, the effect of wind on the aircrafts track across the ground. In order to complete our analogue computer we have to find a means of adding two angles together, the original heading angle and the drift angle. For such an apparently simple problem the mechanical analogue computer  uses a differential. Two input values, one for heading angle, one for drift angle are (algabraically) added to produce track. Track is the angle of the aircrafts path over the ground.


All the above techniques are only a sample of what was done with electromechanical analogue computers. The mechanical systems have their shortcomings and there are numerous other analogue techniques, many of them purely electronic. Vacuum tubes amplifiers were used, and as soon as they became available, transistors. And I’ve not even mentioned a now totally obsolete lost world ‘solid state’ technology called magnetic amplifiers.

Now the analogue computer has had its day, although it arguably reached it technical best, (with integrated circuit operational amplifiers) just as it was being made obsolete by the digital computer. As Robert Heinlein observed, that tends to be the case, by the time a technique is finally perfected, it’s generally obsolete. And so it is with the analogue computer.

Tuesday, 15 December 2009

Bomb Sights

The first bombing raids on London, by the Graf Zeppelin in 1917, democratised warfare as never before. The killing was know no longer confined to the battlefield and  soldiers but now included cities and the civilian population. By the nineteen thirties the prospect of city bombing had gathered pace to the extent that Britain's RAF invested greatly in bombers. (Far more so, in fact, than in the fighters  and radar that would eventually win the Battle of Britain.) These new bombers were to be a deterrent force that would make attack unthinkable.  But when the war began it was soon realised that the accuracy with which the bombers could deliver their payload was quite another matter.



At the start of the Second World War, aircraft navigation, especially at night, could be extremely poor. Prague was bombed only once and that was by accident. The pilot who bombed Prague thought he was bombing Dresden, an error of over a hundred miles.

Then, assuming that the target was found, there was the issue of bomb aiming. In the early days this had been left to the pilots judgement. As aircraft altitudes and speeds increased bombing effectively became more difficult. The fundamental problem of air navigation is the difference between the aircraft's motion through the air and its motion over the ground. To bomb accurately the motion over the ground must be known, but the aircraft instruments of the 1930s and 1940s could only determine motion through the air.

The instruments of the time could measure airspeed with reasonable accuracy and heading can be found from a magnetic compass. But, because of wind, speed and direction over ground rarely corresponds with speed and direction through the air. The air is usually in motion, and any calculations regarding distance travelled, based only on speed through the air and direction pointed will be subject in error. In order to correct speed over the ground, and track (the path of the aircraft over the ground) wind speed and direction must be known.

The first generation bombsights attempted to add in a predicted wind speed based on weather forecasts. But the forecast winds were often way out and the vector sights which allowed the bomb aimer to ‘dial in’ the predicted winds were soon found to be inadequate. But aircraft motion over the ground could be determined by observing and tracking a point on the ground.


The Norden bombsight was one of several computing bombsights developed by the USA, Britain and Germany which were capable of deriving the wind speed and direction from observation of the target. The Norden bombsight was probably the most hyped weapon of the Second World War. It was an improvement on the vector sights its true accuracy was nothing like the claims made of it. And, long after its secrets were well know in Germany, crews had to carry out a post mission procedure of locking the bombsight up that was as useful as the ceremonial changing of the guard outside Buckingham Palace. Germany had long had a comparable bomb sight of its own, the Lotfe 7. And this was well known to the Allies from Lotft 7s found in shot down aircraft.

The RAF precision bombing experts, 617 squadron, used a British designed sight, the SABS (top picture), and very effectively. At their best, 617 could deliver precision weapons such as Tallboy to an accuracy of 125 yards. The Tallboy bomb, devised by Barnes Wallis, was used to bomb the Tirpitz and against the Saumur tunnel.

All these bombsights were tachymetric sights -calculating speed (windspeed) through observation.

Initially the bomb aimer set the known vertical separation (altitude over ground) between the bomber and the target into the bomb sight computer. He then had to manually align a telescope, which was part of the bombsight, on to the target. The bombsight's computer, which was getting airspeed and heading, then continuously calculated a pointing angle for the telescope as the target was approached. This pointing angle steered the telescope through a servo mechanism.


In reality this would only work in ideal, no-wind conditions, and in practice, the target drifts across the field of view of the telescope. The bomb aimer has two controls which he must use to 'null out' the drift. These controls set up a 'vector' in opposition to the actual wind vector, (which is the speed AND direction of the wind). With the drift correctly neutralised the telescope will automatically track the target. And the adjustment of the drift controls has produced values for the direction and strength of the wind. With the wind known the bomb release point can be determined with much greater accuracy.

The American and German tachymetric bombsights were designed for use with aircraft with autopilots. They produced a steering signal which was fed into the autopilot to correct the aircraft heading. An automatic bomb release signal was also produced. The British SABS bombsight drove director lights which the pilot had to follow.



In an earlier blog I mentioned how the guidance technology developed in the Second World War was developed for use in missiles and, eventually, the Apollo moon landings. The technique of tracking an object, manually on a bombsight, was, within ten years fully automated. ICBMs used  automatic star tracking to achieve great accuracy. The submarine launched missile system Polaris is so named because of its ability to automatically track the Pole star.

By the time engineers and airmen had achieved great accuracy the development of nuclear weapons seem to have made accuracy obsolete. The reality has turned out a little differently, bomb accuracy continues to be improved with guidance such as GPS and laser now achieving accuracies of better than 13 metres.

Saturday, 12 December 2009

Waiting for the Telegram

In print the short story can be spare and effective, but in the face of stiff competition from other media it is no longer hugely popular. In his collection of TV monologues, Talking Heads, Alan Bennett has devised a TV format which is very similar to the short story form in its impact, and with the same demands on the writer for economy. Each story is told by a single actor, talking straight to the camera and telling the story. When talking to strangers intimacies can be revealed which cannot be shared with family or friends.


In Waiting for the Telegram Violet tells her story. She is played by veteran actor Thora Hird. Violet is a lady in her nineties, if she lives long enough she’ll receive a telegram from the Queen congratulating her on her hundredth birthday. The story looks back over her long life and the priority that her failing mind has given to various events. This is a brilliantly constructed piece which unfolds most elegantly, which you can see here. Waiting_for_the_Telegram

Violet is hospitalised with some other elderly people and often has trouble finding words. She's been coached to describe a thing when she can't remember the word. Using this method women's breasts become,
                                 "Them two things with pink ends that men like."


Alan Bennett uses this device to put the telegram into an additional context. When Violet can't find the word for telegram she has the line -

            "What is it now? Lad comes on a bike. Folks stood at the door weeping."

Commercial telegram operation began in 1839 and telegrams were used to mark great events in family life. Births, marriages and deaths were announced by telegram. In the First World War the first news that a loved one had been killed came via a telegram. Violet’s generation was promised a war to end wars in 1914 and the memory of the loss of so many young men is still vivid to her.

When she's asked, "What war?"
  
She snaps back angrily, "The proper war. When all the young lads got killed. Never again. That war."

Despite the loss of more recent memories she can still remember the last time she saw her sweetheart. He and her had been left alone together on his last night before he went off to war. Somehow Violet’s sense of propriety, or her shyness, inhibited her. Her sweetheart went off to war unsatisfied. She has regretted this ever since.


And this is a masterly performance from Thora Hird. Almost ninety at the time, and playing a character ten years older. As the tale unfolds she deftly switches voices to recite the words of the nurses and the other inmates. And, despite the sadness of the tale, Bennett still gives Hird a few funny, surrealistic yet typically northern lines. She delivers these with superb timing. - Violet is recalling how Rennie, another elderly, deluded lady inmate who is always telling people that she’s waiting for a taxi.

"Rennie, where is this taxi going to take you?" Violet asks her.

"To my mam and dad's in 1947." says Rennie.

"Well if he can take you there I bet he does a spanking trade."

We hear of the indignities that the elderly patients are subject to: being dressed in the wrong clothes, even given the wrong teeth. But we see the affection that Violet feels for some of the staff. And in particular one of the male nurses, Francis. And we discover that a lady of ninety can still look at a young man's body and admire it.

Then, at the end, after Rennie has died, "well he (the taxi) came in the end." Her nurse friend Francis dies too. By now Violet has had enough, we sense that she won't last much longer.

A telegram brought the United States into the First World War and finally brought the massive slaughter to a close. The Zimmerman telegram was an encrypted communication between the German Foreign Secretary and the German ambassador in Washington. It was intercepted by the British and decrypted by Room 40, Britain’s cipher decryption centre. The conflict finally ended in 1918. Yet it was only twenty two years later that the lie of a war to end wars was revealed and the Second World War started.

Bennett finds a new way with the short story form that was hugely popular in 1918. He gives it a facelift and preserves the superb performance of a fine actor. Waiting for the Telegram is something very special.